Stock Views on Mahindra & Mahindra, Dabur, Reliance Power

Merrill Lynch on Mahindra & Mahindra

WHILE Merrill Lynch has reiterated its ‘underperform’ rating on Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M), it has revised the price target to Rs 536 from Rs 499 due to additional value of listed subsidiaries, and a 4% lower dilution on assumed non-conversion of foreign currency convertible bonds (FCCBs). Merrill Lynch has the following concerns: Unexciting overall prospects of core business, restricted by highly competitive and margineroding utility vehicles segment, as well as substantial investments, which will dilute earnings and return parameters. Over the next three years, capital outlay is estimated at Rs 9,000 crore on an existing base of Rs 7,000 crore. Around 50% of the company’s investments are expected to be related to acquisitions/joint ventures, possibly in new forays, or where the management’s capability is yet to be proven, for example two-wheelers, auto parts etc. Standalone capital expenditure (capex) surge will sharply increase fixed overheads, and therefore, drag down mediumterm profitability, as well as the return ratio.

HSBC on Dabur

HSBC has assigned an ‘overweight’ rating to Dabur India with a price target of Rs 110. The recent sluggishness in the share price can be attributed to the slowdown in growth for foods from 20%+ earlier to around 15% in the past few quarters. However, since the integration with the consumer care division (CCD) has been completed, and supply chain issues have been sorted out, the foods segment is set to return to 20%+ growth in the next quarter. This may be the trigger that the market seeks to re-rate the stock. HSBC has valued Dabur at 21x FY10E earnings per share (EPS) of Rs 5.25 to get a target price of Rs 110. Dabur has averaged a 12-month forward price-earnings (P/E) multiple of 24.6x over the past two years with minimum and maximum P/Es of 17.1x and 29.9x, respectively. The stock is currently trading at 21.1x FY09E EPS. Given its robust business model, which is well-diversified over a large number of segments, with brands targeted at each category of consumers, Dabur is currently trading below its deserved multiple.

BNP Paribas on Reliance Power

BNP Paribas has initiated coverage on Reliance Power by assigning a ‘reduce’ rating. Reliance Power is a power utility at an early stage of development with revenue expected to start only in FY10, when its first power project becomes operational. The company has an ambitious plan to become the second-largest power generator in India by adding ~31 gigawatts (gw) of capacity by FY16. However, the company faces significant headwinds as only one project has attained financial closure. Further, 66% of the land required for its projects is yet to be acquired. Its hydroelectric projects are in very early stages of development with the risk of being shelved. BNP Paribas believes that Reliance Power will find it difficult to prevent project cost escalations on rising equipment and construction costs. Rising interest rates and a global credit crunch can increase debt costs above the company’s estimates.